Press release*Template press release; Version 001; 2008-09-09;Sarah Lahouegue13192022-11-08T13:49:00Z2009-06-11T18:34:00Z2022-11-08T13:49:00Z39795389Copa-Cogeca - European Farmers4412635615CDP(22)4762:108/11/2022Opinion PieceThe Brazilian Butterfly Effect - Will Lula's return mean that the Mercosur agreement will be forced through by the EU Commission? The Brazilian election held on 30th October 2022 was historic in many respects and will have repercussions far beyond the country's borders. For the EU, Lula's election is seen as a signal: the EU-Mercosur trade deal can be taken out of the freezer! In fact, the polemic deal signed with the Latin-American trade block in 2019, has not been yet ratified. Four years ago, the European Parliament and several Member States clearly indicated that they could not support this deal due the substantial negative impact on EU agricultural markets and the environment. Will MEPs and Member States suddenly change their opinion depending on the political colour of the newly elected President?Despite the Council conclusions of 8 May 2018, where Member States asked for Mercosur to remain a mixed agreement, it was reported last month that the European Commission was waiting for the election results to come back with a renewed approach. According to Politico, “To resuscitate the deal, Brussels wants to strip countries of their vetoes and use the EU’s wide-ranging trade powers to ratify the agreement at EU level — which would require majorities in the Council and European Parliament — rather than in the EU’s 27 national parliaments and several regional parliaments. It’s a pathway that is legal, but politically fraught (…).”The manoeuvring - if later confirmed - is shocking. We understand that with the war in Ukraine, there is an urgent need for the EU to find new trade opportunities and to implement existing agreements. We share that goal. However, by pushing for the ratification of the EU-Mercosur deal, the Commission could further compromise Europe's farming sustainability. If there was an outright opposition to the agreement in 2019 already, how could the European farming community not be even more opposed to an agreement that disregards the latest developments, namely the Farm-to-Fork Strategy and the consequences of the war in Ukraine on EU farms and agri-cooperatives? The European Commission will certainly argue that the directive on deforestation affecting imported products, which was passed by the European Parliament in September 2022, strengthens the means of control and the sustainability of the agreement. It would be far from resolving the many problematic points of this agreement when it comes to agriculture. We see at least three issues on which the Commission has failed to provide us with a satisfactory response in the three years since this agreement was signed.An unbalanced agreement, to the detriment of European agriculture Firstly, despite the access granted to EU products, such as wine, dairy, olive oil, some fruits, vegetables and GI’s, the Mercosur agreement is unbalanced in its agricultural chapter, especially for the already fragile agricultural sectors such as beef, poultry, rice, orange juice, sugar and ethanol. Taking the beef sector as an example, it is easy to understand that this agreement will shift the negotiating power from the hands of European farmers to those of the large operators in the Mercosur countries.Cumulative effects that are unsustainable in the long termSecondly, European farmers are concerned about the cumulative and difficult to quantify impacts of all the agreements already signed by the EU. This concern has been confirmed by the Commission's own study on the impact of trade deals on agricultural products! In this context, the agreement between the EU and the Mercosur block could be the last straw that breaks the camel’s back. In the poultry sector, yearly imports from the Mercosur countries (Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay, and Uruguay) will be equivalent to the combined production of Denmark, Finland and Sweden. EU double standards Back in 2019, this agreement would have made things harder for EU farmers, by applying a double standard between what is forbidden in the EU and what is tolerated within our imports. The sugar beet sector is a prime example. With this agreement, Europe will import sugar and ethanol that do not meet our production standards in any way. Brazil alone uses 27 herbicides and insecticides that are banned in Europe.Since the 2019 political agreement, we see a regulatory tsunami unfolding in the EU with the development of the European Green Deal. Dozens of regulatory initiatives impacting agriculture are currently under discussion in Brussels on nature restoration, biodiversity, industrial emissions, the use of plant protection products, animal welfare, etc. On the other hand, the war in Ukraine is profoundly affecting EU food production, causing costs to surge and exceed those of our competitors. This will be particularly visible in the fertiliser and energy markets. The EU has not yet incorporated into the Green Deal discussions the impact of the Russian aggression on EU agriculture, and we strongly denounce it. Being less affected by the consequences of the conflict in Ukraine, the Mercosur countries will see their competitiveness strengthened.Against this backdrop, the implementation of the Green Deal will further increase the gap in standards applied to the EU and Mercosur farmers. This wide gap is untenable for European producers, and the Mercosur agreement will only exacerbate this problem as this agreement was designed many years before the launch of Farm to Fork and the war in Ukraine. It would therefore be both anachronistic and detrimental; thus we firmly denounce it.To put it plain and simple in black and white: any attempt by the Commission to force the passage of this agreement would be truly scandalous and set a dangerous precedent for EU farming. Christiane Lambert, President of Copa -END-Translation in DE, FR, ES, IT, PL, and RO will soon be available on the Copa-Cogeca website.For further information, please contact:Ksenija SimovicSenior Communications ManagerMobile: + 32 473 663 071Ksenija.Simovic@copa-cogeca.eu Jean-Baptiste BoucherCommunications DirectorMobile: + 32 474 840 836jean-baptiste.boucher@copa-cogeca.eu DOCPROPERTY PWThreadMemo \* MERGEFORMAT CDP(22)4762:1 PAGE \* Arabic \* MERGEFORMAT 3| 3R0lGODlh+AA+ANUAAP///15uFcpsGNXV1oKDhKusrYaSUK62itfbxPX19fLaxfX28Hd4eteRUuDg 4GJjZWh3JFhZW+rq6uS1i8DBwXyJQXKAMm1ucJulbcvLzLa2t5GbXuvt4oyNjs11JuHk05eXmcLI p/z28fXj1NF+NevIqPjt4szStqGio6WufLi/mNuaYOi+mtSIQ96jb+7Rt+GtfQAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACH5BAAAAAAALAAAAAD4AD4AAAb/QIBw SCwaj8ikcslsFheGAOTkrFqv2Kx2y+16v0lVYAwBm8/otHrNPh7GY0R7Tq/b7903XE5UKER4gYKD hF4ncAF8ACMkAgIegIWSk5SSC4h8Ix6OjiWVn6ChXi8NDSwmQxh7ACKbnAIvorKztEcjrwITQhxw CwANuC21w8ShE7gCLaiqFQAluCuRxdPUgSbIjyMLFQcAjY4ksdVHHwi+4+hfL9+vkELXJC7i6UMh FmQf9EQjMA2uJA0moDIiosSKFpwawFCQxMSEh54AmGDhz1ELGCOY8Kv4KODAJC8mlCIB8KOWExgM QJBiAEOIJQtCbKgwxoIBFRyacFCxwYDP/5YHVKRYiQiDkZgzx7RUtARlFJYYqCCJmfJeAJsp8ikZ AQxbLiMsXGEjwdCIgoQAjnmNhqQEO2wwtpw4QPdAiJxKEFiFYKAn0SlIDhCt0JfmmBTnjnBQVbOv 1THcHhsoIljpgacBNiQ+orex35pShyxIAYdvCgyPNbf1yknXEBErWL9iYTahC9nJpBHB7ciFzsvd hDBGZCF0kRBwVBBZ8Ng4AChkmH4wXGHzkA9EAygfIgbygu4BXgqBLkUrAOzekSAfs318cyKYjRLR E2CykWftXDycgHDeL1wBPfSWABENcRYyJMDwUGyvNHAEJwnu1xUnZSGBAGbdrKCNYYgEEP8cEYcc VgQvcFhQxAZwmDcEB4NZxxwcHw6B4hgbAKDCAcbNmEgRCMDRjBHreVjEB4j8CECPcMhHxHv74OIa ESZIoxY4FQrBAi4ZGYiMC7pp8kqBQwjQQJVCKCDWClNhJsUCLwhAgggL6FjiE9lZR98YRARZ4xGk iTgfItadh4kR4NlXBIYj1klZh9wxemiSRUxI4BKtcOLOfQ32gYtvRngJjhH+FYGfI4plx15ajrim gqlGCkGfofUQR0R24hmB5Bh4CcEhrLPCsadotB4BHgSbDfdro3MKQWRpRvRZH5SvoLnElRQmcRsn WQJwIDi6ETGlANkyIcIrZAIg57P/PRL/yQIH3GOBigBkl8JRHNYaZADwEoFIewAgwusQmJmYJyK5 ErHsGLXGCyO9ZBg3XMKuwgHrtyYhgZBFSlzTmpYbI6GxI7RVcbEA5XZYnRATgmkhIjEabA4RwwWg xGOtsoyEmicikkRRQ4SIsIUv84hAvgC8SsSEwjAx2xIjO1jmK+EawQ6nBCnAwn4CVlvEcCcLES0T dzK1xGMyJ4HzEIgcC1+yQ2Qn8BGyRrwKGEYPwc6TSWxL8hJTesAxqUpM6DQRBvFWLrsbQCwWCWAP 6oSjNyNiHs1IZKd2kQhkrrnmZMvo+BUnpKBmh7C+gjcSendrxLd/+60Eg2LuMzJu5SYh/ykTaoqt hL9K5D7EnQUr+zkAJHZovPEAD9+EPT6mUBdmpXeshN5MsP70p4Gj9Y5YjnhQykMc7e0EDJbirvzu Evf++TaQPkrjiJhvLv/myc/txHCA/akUEXczoXft3irf9QBnO+2lyxEaMsKEAHgEE7jidHw6386Y ZbbhkScAGMALB3SkmiLwzgq+c4Kz8GWEuqGME9JawpeWALvB6a1iRRCLa27BCapFSmtOEIECohYY REBsZjqrIBzcgAgIZKcCPxRC3KoQNiccDINE3N8QqOUI1RlhZCk8QqVS9TcBhMwWKwQAFQVgRW/g EA0+E5IT5KQEDr0NWQEgjE/sEjz34f/JCvdqWRKaWML0DeFjX5nWK2A4Rah1kXFIuJYjBjKlwRUB kAzswiV8VYV71RFtcJgXEXpUAaItATwBCJQSJjkGJS3hbH2U4hAkxcMibDF2DRSLI/XmRTAa8FtW hJ341IA/JRRsAdlxznUktzU1XqF4ARCmwYygozcaIVeozJkqt2epULEiW2PkUhFGMLtw0XJS++De PNpUQyMo0hGR7AIyk/gcCByLPqYkAnjUBoAoQAADdcknjnQ3BGfFkwi8aNWREKHMdsonZvkCph8J ByAW+KEELvAA3nTpgYUo4AXnBGcXE1ICP8CAe44EAEg7qoAJDGiXaqCPBUSpihixTwr/dXwRTI0Q s+ORIYMMmynD9OislR4BRcG5Fz1jZp/MDWFUayGCCCTFmi/+rQGzw0YLujVGryjSmmjgWsE4EIWu iYY6v2QMBIj2RJuWJl8fsEoFgocAmvxLOD7aaleJwKEApAAvF+oQBDjAAQscixGsCWlauIeLcBxh Ww1YKmumeoRv4cIDHZUeG1YlsQOkwDAGEGWcfEUXDBDFAJ4EQBrNSoZAXXADnbWKJntY2cvSaDMv PR5oTRWH+6yAsA3AqghYENUVqExTjnBa4Rr0Wyi54C0JQgVXSlHcNLCrrplh5xAQgJoibqCgzxmO X/V5AOjya5PVLREGQrsi15ZmA/wE/0AIoJs4ZQVMumVqpcfSOUDBKoCQGaPvHTgQNCuUgwkvhYB0 EWA5JnyAvL5Mr2L6yyNR2gGx+igEfRQshCC9NcJsgDCGBbEXAC90w3PQMIjv8OEJGnPEGTYgiunw GAf3DA6XXLEZRCzjNsBTCWn1U43VQOMdrwF6wvxAZezq4zX0uMhpGHJjfOIvCiN5Czr0g3yfbAYE XEYlZGgJTqjM5S57+ctgDrOYx0zmMpv5zGhOs5rXzOY2u/kIKCCAA978hQTMuRASuPM4BnCBASSA zl4YAAEkUYBBo0PQgK6znvFAgAEAIM9ayAABCiAESgNgAI4uQAY6AIBNg2DOEsgACv86kAEhOAAE IJDAo+OsASFoQNKWfjQILlCABGiAACj4MwU2DYACFDoDFCBAqQFw6k9fmgKf9jQdEjDqUkuAAkKg gASeXQBo31oDut50rqNNgFZfGgSkfjQFChDuIQyg2abuAAgy4GgKaAAFzy6CBOIM7QGo29HEBrej n33rYUsA1XMeQAY+PQBwl5oCFwABpjEN7Us7+tpC0DYRMvCADDCg1RGoNKUJcPEBPGDcD0jAACJQ 7QhIIAEP0AAIBv3uAVwcABy3uLdtzQBMd0DQKID5AygdgQ5o4AEMoPjJd46CC/R65yN3Nx0I4HOT IxrmmO75uYPOABDofNODRrjWAdD/AQpQwOkRWPcDVC0Enwsd5RrQAMkB0HMKPH0IFyC1BiSQcrUP vdoPcMDISf0ARye8AA/odQTg3fWv5/niEvC1A4wOgKAXgAFad0DFvV12aEua7RqHeq9z3ni3M6Ds Ggi2EDI+BA1svNS+NrehhYBoAjQ8An+uOdQtLoSxFyDnfP7zHBIAe6673dCN5nPtQZ3xbgOA9wkQ NgAowOkhBD/wmi9Co2kPc57/+e2X/ryrmw+CamsfBbXuPQoUzvg+F8DqRGi05lOfd5Q3vtQqd7nu nc8Ajg+a9KlX/6Q1/nRfF+ACBEAAETAADsAAEbB26pd6rDdoDtABBzho6od5mtdo/4AXgH2ngATw cXMwcgFIa08XfIZGepgXgQMYAfVXf712AQeIacCHb8unggN4e5lHeoj2gOc3BArof5ZWaDC3gB5n gQOQgzDoaAlIaSAQepxmgvaXAAxwAcMmBN2GaXOGfxvnaB1gad3Xf752c5iWABdgeVXYa7GGaFd4 aRCIb6SnfwOgATXXhQq4fBrIBh63cBLwgSw4ekNQfGhIdxoghZKnaiAIhfgmeXNGgc0HfhKIfbeG gzvoa5x3g9oXbC63cAmQen84gZlGaZ4GbRHQhwQYbX03BKgmBLE3Z2WofovohZh2AbGXARnAisfH dqrWfes3hhCIemeIh5goeX/2Z/9vCAC02AZ5F4sud3wD+HRfeGlGh2vEFnhl+GjFqIp2yHrlt4pC QGuJuHrEFgF3RgHaB3mvCIUYN4sawIuPJobZd3x9VovGeAGq5nOk6HyUR3cMwACUVnQMsHOax4RN +HkjdwH1KARNGIAAgI8PYHVFqHpHl4G5KIFqCIwAGHipx2cZSHZs8HMEcAEOgHJN2HdPR3EZCG0M qY+Sx3G1BnQAeYfRx48XEIr1mI88t4BFgAIPwHSN95KxB5AM8GcPEJGzWJMSSWkcmZJcB3kYqH0/ eHHeWJFEIHIu2IWqtpGkiGkLqHfzh2lk14VzJpXTNgR2Zmp+tpW6N4h/JpXENgBrqtaVDmeRbaB3 dyZyDrCRXykEdXhnwvaJU4lvcHlyc2mWx0eAakmArndppLhoYJmVLuhwukcAdTh/epeWZLeXvYiW aglpdEmVivkF2Jdo0peYdbZvw2gG2jgNm8mZzueZXrB4B8h5ojkIQQAAOw== Copa - Cogeca | European Farmers European Agri-Cooperatives61, Rue de Trèves | B - 1040 Bruxelles | www.copa-cogeca.eu EU Transparency Register Number | Copa 44856881231-49 | Cogeca 09586631237-74